Week 6 Early Modern World. Conducting research.
(Jun 15-19) Due: Module 6, Research Proposal / ROL & WW Intro to Part 4, Ch 13 (Empires & Encounters),
Ch 14 (Commerce & Consequence), Ch 15 (Religion & Science)
Happy Monday everyone. The online debate format was not viable. I won’t ding anyone for not getting it right, but I will give some extra credit to those who came closest. I moved back to the Bay Area this past week (I was sheltering in place in Modoc, as you might recall – am now back in East Palo Alto.) As a consequence, I got behind in my grading… I will be finishing your Xinchen/Claudius papers first and then your Quiz 2s. I’m feeling like some of you (maybe all of you… maybe me, too!) could use an easier week. It’s hard to decide what to omit, but let’s modify our reading load for this week as follows:
Chapter 13: Just read the first 3 sections of the chapter: European Empires in the Americas; Comparing Colonial Societies in the Americas; and The Steppes and Siberia, the Making of a Russian Empire.
Chapter 14: Entire chapter. Sorry, there’s no section I can cut here.
Chapter 15: Just read the last 2 sections: Persistence and Change in Afro-Asian Cultural Traditions; and A New Way of Thinking, The Birth of Modern Science
1) For each chapter, just pick one sidebar or big picture question per chapter to reflect on in a blog post. So that’s 3 blogs posts this week, one for each of the 3 chapters.
2) I’m also going to dial back your research requirement a bit. You will NOT have to write a research paper. You WILL have to write an Annotated Bibliography(which will require you to follow an academically rigorous method for gathering information), and you WILL have to write a letter to someone, or a social media post, in which you use the historical knowledge gained through your research to make the case that the reader should act (or perhaps think) in a certain way with respect to a certain issue. Your first step, then, is to think of an issue about which you are passionate (or curious), and about which you would like to be able to speak more knowledgeably. Examples follow below. For this week, just think of your topic and do the Annotated Bibliography. Please email your AB to me when it’s done, and don’t begin your letter until I’ve had a chance to look at the AB.
Examples:
* You are passionate about your position on racial equality. Would you be better able to convince others to think or act differently if you were more knowledgeable about the history of racial equality?
* You are curious about how the present pandemic compares to other pandemics that have afflicted humanity. Would you be better able to put it in context for yourself and others if you were more knowledgeable about the historical details of other pandemics from the past?
* You are passionate about leadership within the context of a democracy. Would you be more confident of your opinions if they were grounded in more historical reading and reflection? Perhaps go all the way back to Plato – what did he have to say about how democracy would play out? How about Machiavelli? MLK Jr?
* You are passionate about some wrong of the past that hasn’t yet been righted. Is there a person or organization you could write to, explaining why now is the time for that wrong to be righted? Perhaps suggesting a way to do that? Would your argument be stronger if it were grounded in solid historical research about the wrong?
* You feel strongly that our president (current or future) should be more knowledgeable about some aspect of the historical past. You could write a letter addressed to both candidates running for president in 2020 and give them a little history lesson on that subject area, explaining why you feel it is so important for them to know the subject area more deeply if they are going to serve as president.
* Etc. These are just examples to get you thinking…
Once you have chosen a subject area you’d like to learn more about, follow the instructions below to write an Annotated Bibliography on that subject area. Remember that the NDNU librarians are in fact available over summer term for online help if you need them! Send me your AB by email when you’re done.
Annotated Bibliography
The purpose of this assignment is to help you prepare for your research assignment by identifying the main concepts in your research topic and finding relevant and authoritative sources that will help you analyze your topic.
Assignment addresses IL criteria- Determine the extent of information needed, access the needed information, evaluate information and its sources critically.
Instructions:
· Write 1-2 sentences describing your research topic and identifying the key concepts in your research topic.
· Find three relevant sources on your research topic. Examples include:
o print or electronic booksfound using the library catalog
o scholarly articlesfound using one of the library databases
o authoritativewebsitesor news articles
· Cite each source using APA or MLA format. List your annotations in alphabetical order.
· Create an annotation for each source that includes:
o 1-2 sentences explaining how you found your source. What keywords and search terms were useful? What was the best combination of terms? Why did you choose those words? Where did you search for your source (which database, search engine, etc.) and why?
o 2-3 sentences summarizing the content of the resource. What are the main points? Is your source a primary source or a secondary source? Scholarly or popular? Based on fact or opinion?
o 2-3 sentences evaluating the author(s) and publisher. Who is the author? What are his/her credentials as an expert on this subject? Are they affiliated with a university or college? What are their degrees? Have they published other articles or books on this topic? Hint: do a web search for your author to find out more about them. Who is the publisher? What are their credentials? Do they have a bias or agenda in publishing the information?
o 2-3 sentences describing the relevance of the resource to your research. How will you use it in your paper? Is the information in this resource general (like for background information) or specific, and how can you tell? How does this source differ from the others you chose? What perspectives or aspects of the topic does this source represent?
· Has this assignment helped you prepare to write your research paper? Please explain why or why not.